I don't know the value of Studebakers but a non-running two-door for a running four-door plus a parts car (not sure of a parts interchange benefit between the two) doesn't sound like a bad trade depending on which fits your plans better. Being a two-door the Stude is probably worth as much or more than the other two (but again, depending on condition). It really sounds like it's more of a personal preference decision than one of dollar value.


.